Tal Cohen's Bookshelf: A Collection of Personal Opinions about Books
Read Log, March-April 2021
By Tal Cohen Sunday, 30 May 2021
Wilhelm Meister’s Apprenticeship by Goethe (original title: Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre; I’ve read the Hebrew translation, by Isaac Kafkafi). You can’t study the theory of bildungsroman without starting here. Now, if it was also a book I could enjoy reading, that would have been great... Some parts of the book reminded me of (much later!) books that I’ve previously read; for example, Meister’s stories about his childhood group theater reminded me of I, Barak a (Hebrew) children’s book that was a formative experience in my childhood. One wonders if Ben-Canaan was familiar with Meister. The script-burning scene in Book II reminded me of Bulgakov. And so on. But from about halfway through, I was mostly reminded of parodies about cheap melodramas and soap operas. Yes, of course there is depth, layers of meaning (think about all the cross-dressing) and historical significance to this novel; but sadly, it did not age well.




Great Expectations by Charles Dickens. Dickens’s novel of a failed coming-of-age story, in contrast, did age well, and was a fun read. And the original intended ending (don’t buy a copy without it) makes it even better.

Two scenes in the book are worth mentioning as, perhaps, the earliest instances of very common tropes: First, in Chapter LIII, we find the villain talking too much before getting to business (in this case, Orlick to killing Pip), which in turn allows help to arrive in the nick of time. Unlike in James Bond movies, though, this scene actually includes an explanation: Orlick is talking while drinking, and he is drinking in order to build up the courage needed to carry on the act. (The website “TV Tropes” calls this Evil Gloating; its list of examples from literature has nothing earlier, but then again, it doesn’t include Great Expectations either.)

The other trope is Abel Magwitch burning two money bills as a show-off of his wealth (Chapter XXXIX). Here, TV Tropes lists Dostoevsky’s The Idiot as an example from literature that’s almost as early, but was still published some eight years later.




The Language Lover’s Puzzle Book: Lexical Perplexities and Cracking Conundrums from Across the Globe by Alex Bellos. I was gifted this book by a colleague from work, and... it was so much fun! A mix of logic puzzles and random linguistic facts from around the globe. I normally dislike logic puzzles, and with few exceptions, I didn’t actually try to solve these; I was reading for the linguistics, not the puzzles. The nature of the book means that all these random facts were truly random, focusing on the bizarre, obscure, or otherwise very different than what most of us are accustomed to in our own languages; but they were also facts, which is what makes the book so fascinating.

Puzzle 99, “Hungarians in a Field,” is an extreme example of how some of the riddles are basically logic puzzles that can be solved with little or no knowledge in linguistics. Other puzzles are very different. Puzzle 33, “The Kings of Old Persia,” is an amazing true-story decipherment of ancient Persian cuneiform texts. Here’s the complete puzzle:

33. The Kings of Old Persia
The following texts were discovered in the ruins at Persepolis, and date from somewhere between the sixth and fourth century BC. Each was carved above a figure on a doorway.

Text 1:
𐎭 𐎠 𐎼 𐎹 𐎺 𐎢 𐏁 𐏐𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐏐 𐎺 𐏀 𐎼 𐎣 𐏐 𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐏐 𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐎠 𐎴 𐎠 𐎶 𐏐 𐎻 𐎡 𐏁 𐎫 𐎠 𐎿 𐎱 𐏃 𐎹 𐎠 𐏐 𐎱 𐎢 𐏂

Text 2:
𐎧 𐏁 𐎹 𐎠 𐎼 𐏁 𐎠 𐏐 𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐏐 𐎺 𐏀 𐎼 𐎣 𐏐 𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐏐 𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐎠 𐎴 𐎠 𐎫 𐏐 𐎭 𐎠 𐎼 𐎹 𐎺 𐏃 𐎢 𐏁 𐏐 𐎧 𐏁 𐎠 𐎹 𐎰 𐎡 𐎹 𐏃 𐎹 𐎠 𐏐 𐎱 𐎢 𐏂

Translate the inscriptions.

In fairness, Bellos follows the puzzle immediately with, “You may have just burst out laughing at the difficulty of this problem.” And he then guides you to how, given some historic information provided previously (e.g., the dynasties of Cambyses and Hystaspes, and the common title format used in Persia, all of which were known to the researchers that deciphered the scripts), this can actually be solved. And it’s absolutely fascinating.

I feel like I’ve learned so much from this book -- that Tok Pisin (which I’ve never heard of before) is an amazing language, for example, or the history of the alphabets for the blind: Braille, the much-cooler New York Point, the minimalistic and elegant Japanese Braille, and more. If you enjoy linguistics, you will probably love this book.
______________________
New Reviews Notification
To receive notifications as new reviews are published, consider following the RSS feed.
[Post a comment on this entry]
  [Permalink to this entry]
©1997-2020 by Tal Cohen, all rights reserved. [About]